4

Bryan Arenales and Amaya Espinal on the Love Island USA reunionCredit: YouTube/Peacock

4

Andy Cohen confronted Bryan about cheating rumorsCredit: YouTube/Peacock
He brought up a viral video of Bryan at a club partying with other women.

Andy said, “Bryan, there was a video that sparked a lot of rumors about you cheating, partying with other girls. We know the internet had a lot of opinions, but walk us through what’s going on.”

Bryan responded, “They’re trying to just throw any hate my way. And within the cheating video, the hosting I got paid to be there. I used to bartend back in the day.

“I had a lapse of judgment and we’ve talked about it.”

When Andy asked him to clarify the “lapse of judgment,” he responded, “Uh, pouring shots around, giving the crowd shots.”

Amaya defended, “I am not a woman who would be with someone who doesn’t respect me. If I am still with him, it’s clearly because the relationship dynamic is healthy and great.”

Co-star Chris Seeley, who was with Bryan that night, said, “Ain’t s**t happen.”

FAN BACKLASH

But fans weren’t convinced, as they felt Bryan wasn’t being truthful because of his uncomfortable body language.

One fan fired, “Bryan lying [so much] in the reunion. Amaya deserved better.
Love Island USA winners revealed as outraged viewers insist fan-favorite couple was ‘robbed’ in ‘worst finale ever’
A second fan said, “Bryan look guilty as hellllll.”

A third commented, “Andy asking Bryan abt the cheating rumors and Bryan looking uncomfortable as hell.. HE’S GUILTYYY.”

A fourth wrote, “Andy getting to the bottom of things IMMEDIATELY. Got Bryan shaking in his boots already.”

SPLIT RUMORS

On Monday morning, fans noticed that Amaya and Bryan were no longer following each other on Instagram.

Many fans suspected that they parted ways shortly after winning the series, in which they chose to split their $100,000 prize money evenly.

Trouble in paradise first started just weeks after the finale episode.

After going on a press tour, Amaya returned home to New York, while Bryan went to Boston.

The two appeared to interact less on Instagram during their time apart.

LOVE STORY?

Amaya and Bryan, they were announced the winners of Love Island USA during the finale earlier this month.

Amaya said during her speech, “Every decision led me to finding my personal prince charming. I met you, a man who fills up my cup and embraces the waterfall of my emotions.

“You make me believe fairytales are true because I am currently living in one with you right now.

“This is the end of our journey on Love Island, but the beginning of our fairytale. Cinderella finally found her perfect glass slipper.”

Bryan responded, “You said I was the water to your fire, but you are my peace to this madness.

“I can’t wait to continue taking steps forward together. And keep watering the seed we planted.”

Amaya was one of the first bombshells to enter the villa, as she joined the show during episode 5.

Bryan joined the show in Casa Amor and had a steamy romance with Andreina Santos.

When back in the villa, the contestants played the mailbox challenge, where they wrote anonymous letters to express their true feelings.

When Amaya’s exes complained about her moving too quickly in relationships, Bryan came to her defense.

After Andreina was eliminated, Amaya recoupled with Bryan.

The two even went to the Hideaway after just days together.

4

Amaya is no longer following Bryan on InstagramCredit: Peacock

4

Bryan denied cheating rumorsCredit: Peacock