She made that clear when critiquing The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star’s first routine of a Cha Cha for Prince Night.

The seasoned judge wasn’t as enthusiastic about Whitney and her partner Mark Ballas’s performance as the rest of the ballroom.

However, it wasn’t because of her moves, but due to her “focusing on the technique” too much, which Carrie Ann pointed out she hadn’t done in her previous dances.

Derek, on the other hand, had a completely different take on the pair’s routine and ripped Carrie Ann for her harsh feedback.

“Carrie Ann, you are out of your mind!” the former pro DWTS said before praising Whitney’s “perfect” performance.

He also noted that dancing a Cha Cha so late in the game was “really risky,” but the Hulu star had gotten “better and better.”

Fellow judge Bruno Toniolo agreed, and they both gave scores of 10, while Carrie Ann locked in a score of 9.

Fans were outraged by Carrie Ann’s less-than-impressed remarks, especially when the other judges had the opposite opinion.

One X user wrote, “Shocked Carrie Ann didn’t like Whitney’s dance enough to give her a 10.”

Another said, “Carrie ann ruining another whitney perfect score i have to laugh.”

A third remarked, “Carrie Ann scoring Alix and Whitney appropriately… what’s going on?”

And a fourth echoed, “Carrie Ann is out of her damn mind! Mark and Whitney danced a perfect Cha Cha to 1999!”

Carrie Ann had a slight change in her tune during the second round when she praised the duo for delivering her favorite routine of theirs to date in the competition.

However, she and Derek butted heads once again when she slipped in that they experienced “a bit of a hop,” despite her applauding them seconds earlier.

 

Derek slammed her as “crazy,” prompting co-host Alfonso Ribeiro to step in and move things along.

Carrie Ann has been accused all season of “favoritism,” particularly of coming down hard on the female competitors.

Her words might have had serious weight on viewers, as Whitney ended up with the fewest votes and was eliminated.

A woman in a purple sequined dress and a man in a white ruffled shirt standing together.
Whitney and her partner, Mark Ballas, ended up receiving the fewest votes and were eliminatedCredit: Disney+
 

Three judges on the show "Dancing with the Stars" sitting at a desk with the show's logo.
The judges, particularly Carrie Ann, didn’t go easy on the contestants for the semi-finals
 

Carrie Ann Inaba talking on Dancing with the Stars.
Carrie Ann has been accused of ‘favoritism’ and for coming down harder on the female competitors