The Traitors producers are quietly lining up the most explosive season in the show’s history – a first-ever All-Stars edition stacked with the franchise’s most ruthless and unforgettable players.

The U.S. Sun can exclusively reveal casting talks are already underway with the most buzzed-about players from all four seasons in talks to return.

Reality TV contestants Ekin-Su Cülcüloglu, Deontay Wilder, Dan Gheesling, Tamra Judge, Marcus Jordan, Chris Tamburello, Shereé Whitfield, Carsten Bergersen, Mercedes "MJ" Javid, Johnny Devenanzio, Pahaedra Parks, Sandra Diaz-Twine, Peter Weber, John Bercow, Janelle Pierzina, Larsa Pippen, and Maksim Chmerkovskiy sit around a large round table with host Alan Cumming standing behind them in a scene from "The Traitors."
The Traitors Season 2 cast, which includes Peter Weber, Phaedra Parks, and Parvati Shallow, sit at the roundtable to banish their first victimCredit: Getty
As Season 4 continues airing on Peacock, casting is currently being finalized for Season 5, which is expected to be a normal season with an all-new celebrity cast.

However, behind the scenes, bosses are also preparing a Traitors All-Star season for the following year – a move insiders say is meant to raise the stakes after several wildly successful seasons.

“Traitors production are actively casting for Season 5 and putting the finishing touches on that cast,” a source exclusively told The U.S. Sun.

“But they’re also already assembling an All-Star cast for the following year, Season 6, which will be the first time the show’s ever done that.”

After five seasons, producers believe they now have a deep bench of breakout stars capable of delivering the most intense, strategic, and chaotic season yet.

“They feel after 5 seasons, they will have plenty of big names to choose from to make the season the most intense and entertaining one yet.

“They want to keep the show fresh and exciting even for people who watch year after year.

“An all-star season heightens the stakes and adds an entirely new dynamic to the formula,” the insider added.

In terms of who the show would cast for the highly-demanded All-Star season?

A list of names have already been put together that includes fan-favorites and villains from all of the past seasons, The U.S. Sun has learned.

Those names, according to the insider, include: Cirie Fields and Arie Luyendyk Jr. from Season 1, Phaedra Parks, Peter Weber, and Parvati Shallow from Season 2, Boston Rob Mariano, Bob the Drag Queen, Dylan Efron, and Gabby Windey, from Season 3.

And to round out the list, the current season’s stars, Lisa Rinna, and Rob Rausch, are also being included in the conversation.

Cirie Fields with her arms raised, wearing a zebra print cardigan.
Cirie Fields is widely considered the best Traitor of all time after winning Season 1Credit: Getty
 

Rob "Boston Rob" Mariano at the NBCUniversal FYC Emmy Luncheon.
Survivor legend Boston Rob Mariano has had a huge career resurgence since becoming a fan-favorite TraitorCredit: Getty
 

Dylan Efron smiling with his hands clasped, facing a woman with her back to the camera, during "The Day of Reckoning is Upon Us" episode of The Traitors.
Dylan Efron became a breakout star of Season 3 as one of the winnersCredit: Getty
 

Phaedra Parks smiling at a table set with food and flowers.
Housewives alum Phaedra Parks ruled the turret during Season 2 of The TraitorsCredit: Getty
While no contracts have been finalized, The Traitors insiders say the goal is clear: put together a cast of proven schemers, fan favorites, and polarizing personalities for what producers want to be the most talked-about season in The Traitors franchise.

The All-Stars concept has been heavily demanded by fans online, with viewers repeatedly calling for returning players who already know the game to get another shot.

“We NEED an all-star season of The Traitors. Bring back the real masterminds and let them go to war,” one fan begged.

“An All-Stars Traitors season would be insane. No newbies, no learning curve – just straight chaos,” another wrote online.

“If Peacock does an All-Stars season with Cirie, Boston Rob, and Phaedra, I’m glued to my TV,” a third said.

New episodes of The Traitors Season 4 drops at 9pm ET, 6pm PT every Thursday on Peacock.

Peter Weber on "The Traitors" reality TV show.
Peter Weber played a faithful game during Season 2 that included some of the year’s most talked about momentsCredit: Getty
 

Lisa Rinna in a black sailor-style dress and hat, speaking with Johnny Weir in a gold sequined top, at a banquet for "The Traitors" reality TV show.
Lisa Rinna was an iconic Season 4 Traitor before her shocking banishmentCredit: Getty
 

Rob Rausch on the reality TV series The Traitors.
Love Island alum Rob has shocked fans with his strategic gameplayCredit: Getty
 

Arie Luyendyk Jr. from The Traitors smiling and opening a door.
Former Bachelor Arie Luyendyk Jr. was a controversial figure in Season 1 which led to an explosive game-ending move on the finaleCredit: Getty