Joy Taylor (Photo via X)
Despite the backlash, Joy Taylor stood firm on her comments, doubling down during another segment where she emphasized the importance of personal boundaries in relationships. She explained that, based on past experiences, she knows exactly what she’s looking for — and what she’s unwilling to tolerate.

While critics accused her of being “too picky” or “unrealistic,” many fans came to her defense, applauding her for knowing her worth and setting clear standards. Whether people agree or not, Taylor’s unapologetic attitude continues to spark conversations online, cementing her place as one of the most talked-about personalities in sports media today.

Joy Taylor is taking some heat online after making some claims about her dating life that people simply do not believe.

Taylor has been in the news for all the wrong reasons lately, but that’s hardly slowed her down. She’s been back on television while making her regular podcast appearances despite the negative publicity.

The ‘SPEAK’ host made a curious claim while doing the latter this week, putting it out there that she won’t date any man who’s involved with other women, nor will she hook up with anyone who’s very religious.

Check her out in the clip below:

TRENDING: Fox Sports Joy Taylor says that she will not date a man who is involved with other women while they are in a relationship.

Taylor also says that she will never date a religious man.

…pic.twitter.com/OBrBIhNdwv

— MLFootball (@_MLFootball) May 6, 2025

Fans found this all a bit rich since Taylor has been the subject of some questionable claims over the past few months.

“When she speaks, she is lying. Joy Taylor embarrasses herself every time she talks because—-she refuses to be genuine. This is some more phony baloney,” one wrote in the comments.

This woman literally slept with men to get to where she’s at today. She’s probably slept with a coworker she’s ever encountered. She is literally a narcissistic female—-as fraud as they get. She takes no responsibility—-she has no morals and zero principles.
When she speaks, she…

— Joshua Tully (@ThaJungleKiDD) May 6, 2025

“True true, she only dates bosses, CEOs and anyone over 40,” said another.

True true, she only dates bosses, CEOs and anyone over 40

— Aamir (@aamirl_) May 6, 2025

“She is completely deluded on her demand – she speaks as if she is in such high demand by top tier men,” one user claimed.

She is completely deluded on her demand – she speaks as if she is in such high demand by top tier men

— MansaMusa (@DMichaelMG) May 6, 2025

“Well she is narrowing down her choices a lot then. I think the issue might be no one wants to date her at all,” someone else suggested.

Well she is narrowing down her choices a lot then. I think the issue might be no one wants to date her at all

— Carter Speer (@CommanderSpeer) May 6, 2025

Why Does Everyone Think Joy Taylor Is Lying?

Joy Taylor (Photo via Instagram)
The comments above stem from Taylor’s being named in a lawsuit that claims she had intimate relationships with former FOX executive Charlie Dixon and co-host Emmanuel Acho to further her career.

A former hairstylist at FOX, Noushin Faraji, made the claims in a bombshell suit late last year, accusing Dixon, Taylor, and Skip Bayless of various infringements. Taylor is alleged to have been verbally abusive toward Faraji, who says he told her of her plans to falsely accuse Dixon of sexual assault if things didn’t go her way.

The network recently fired Dixon following his name coming up in yet another suit.