Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese (Photo By Grace Smith/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images)
The early returns are in, and Caitlin Clark is once again leading the charge. With over half a million fan votes already, 515,993 to be exact, the Indiana Fever rookie sensation is pacing toward back-to-back All-Star appearances. And if the current numbers hold, she won’t be alone from her team.

Clark isn’t just dominating the scoreboard, she’s also lighting up the All-Star ballot. Joining her in the top 10 are Fever teammates Aliyah Boston (446,961 votes), Kelsey Mitchell (277,664), and Lexie Hull (217,438). Add it all up, and Indiana fans are showing out in force. With the 2025 All-Star Game set to take place at Gainbridge Fieldhouse, their enthusiasm isn’t all that surprising. But not everyone is thrilled.

Fans Call Out Voting System After Fever Floods Top 10

Sophie Cunningham and Caitlin Clark huggingIndiana Fever Sophie Cunningham hugs Indiana Fever Caitlin Clark (Photo Via Imagn Images)
While Clark and company celebrate early support, the broader WNBA community isn’t staying quiet. Some fans and social media users are raising red flags about how much sway one team’s fanbase seems to have.


“Y’all better vote. Y’all are literally letting fans of one team dictate the entire All Star game,” one user posted on X.

Another added, “I don’t think people have understood the concept of fan votes.”

Some took issue with the system itself, not just the votes. “It’s not just up to fan voting thank God Cuz this flawed,” one comment read. “The media actually gonna save this All-Star Game.”

Even with the top-tier names like Napheesa Collier (484,758 votes), A’ja Wilson (394,600), and Breanna Stewart (367,819) rounding out the leaderboard, the presence of multiple Fever players, especially those not considered All-Star locks, has sparked fresh debate around the voting.

Paige Bueckers, the rookie standout for the Dallas Wings, also made an impression with 312,920 votes, signaling strong national support despite her first year in the league. But the overwhelming support for Indiana players has raised questions about balance.

Fan voting accounts for 50 percent of the total selection process, with media and player votes comprising the rest. The WNBA will close the voting window on June 28, with final rosters announced shortly after.

The All-Star Game tips off on July 19 in Indianapolis. If early results are any indicator, the Fever fanbase might already have homecourt advantage